Even though we know they both swim for the United States at the end of the day, we still can’t resist siding with either Team Phelps or Team Lochte. As the top two swimmers in the world, it’s only natural that Michael Phelps and Ryan Lochte share a little competition both in and out of the pool. To fuel the rivalry even more, we’ve created a Phelps vs. Lochte poll to test your team loyalty and find out who the ultimate Olympian is.

Who’s sexier while #Winning?  

Phelps with his stoked splashes, or Lochte with his fist of triumph?

Who would have a more successful modeling career? 

Phelps the G-Qutie, or Lochte the Men’s Health Heartthrob?

Who made this hat look less stupid?

Phelps did by incorporating it into an “undercover look,” or Lochte did by distracting the eye with an equally as stupid necklace?

Who has more swag?

Lochte with his gangster grillz, or Phelps with his golden groupies?

Whose laugh is cuter? 

Lochte’s big belly laugh, or Phelps’s adorable giggle?

Whose six-pack is more seductive?

Phelps’s tempting torso, or Lochte’s killer cuts?

Who’s a bigger stud in a suit? 

Phelps in this clean-cut and classic getup, or Lochte in this edgy ensemble?

Who has a prettier pooch? 

Lochte with his precious Pinscher, or Phelps with his heart-melting mutt?

Whose Olympic tattoo is hotter? 

Phelps’s Speedo stamp, or Lochte’s branded bicep?

Who’s a more charming mama’s boy? 

 Lochte with his love for Ileana, or Phelps with his devotion to Debbie?

We definitely know who our votes are for, but we’ll keep our mouths shut and let you decide for yourself. Let us know if you’re Team Phelps or Team Lochte in the comments below. Let the debating begin!