When we first met 19-year-old gymnast John Orozco, he was a relatively unknown Olympic hopeful starring in a Gym Class Heroes music video. The cameo gave him instant star power as he headed into the Olympics.

Olympic Hopeful John Orozco Joins Gym Class Heroes for ‘The Fighter’ [VIDEO]

Not only will John be remembered as an Olympian but also for something else—a video that he posted on YouTube in December of 2011, almost a full year before the Olympics.

I like to sing! I have some vids on youtube if you wanna see! Bad or Good reviews I’m gonna keep singing anyway lol =P

— John Orozco (@JohnW_Orozco) August 6, 2012

We did a little digging and found this video of John singing to none other than Jordyn Wieber, Aly Raisman, and Mckayla Maroney of the Fab Five gymnastics team. “It’s not Justin Bieber and it’s not going to be Taylor Swift,” says John.

So what song did he sing to the girls? Watch the video below to find out! Do you think John has was it takes to win “American Idol?”